DAB sounds worse than FM

BBC on-demand radio streams now at higher quality
 
BBC might nobble the live Internet streams to help DAB
Home
 
DAB/DAB+
 
Digital 
Satellite
Freeview
 
DRM
 
Internet 
Radio
Tech
 
Software
Downloads
DAB 
Samples
Newsletter
 
Contact
 Us
Introduction to DAB
Incompetent adoption of DAB
When will FM be switched off?
BBC DAB Multiplex
Digital Radio Bit Rates
Wasted DAB Capacity
DAB Around the World
Design of DAB
DAB vs DAB+ technology
T-DMB vs DAB+
Coverage Maps
DAB Summary
 
DAB Radios
DAB CD Portable Stereos
DAB Personal Radios
DAB Micro Systems
DAB Clock Radios
Digital radio via satellite
Satellite Receivers
UK satellite radio bit rates
UK satellite HDTV bit rates
UK satellite TV bit rates
Broadband Internet Radio
Internet Radio
Wi-Fi Internet radios
Introduction to Wi-Fi radios
Multicast - radio at high quality
Audio Advice
Aerials
MPEG Audio Coding
Bit Rate vs Audio Quality
MP2 vs AAC+
Audio Processing
FEC Coding
OTA software upgrades
COFDM
Analogue vs Digital Radio
Bandwidth
RF Carriers
Sampling
RF Antennas
Links
         
Digital radio via satellite
Satellite Receivers

 

Digital Radio via Satellite (DSat) 

For home listening digital radio via satellite is a far better option than DAB. The reason for this is that the bit rates are either higher or the same on satellite as they are on DAB and the equipment doesn't cost very much.

Take the BBC stations; on DAB for the majority of the day Radios 1-4 are transmitted at 128, 128, 192, and 128kbps respectively. The same stations on satellite are all 192kbps. The streams over both DAB or DSat are both encoded in MP2 format so the DSat streams are of higher quality. There are no problems due to audio processing or vinyl screwing up the audio quality because the encoders don't run out of bits.

The reason why the bit rates are higher on satellite than on DAB is that on satellite the bandwidth available is far higher in the satellite band in comparison with the VHF band which is where DAB presently transmits. There is nothing inherently wrong with DAB it just lacks enough bandwidth for the stations to properly exploit the system by using the higher bit rates.

 

Sky Subscription

It is not necessary to get a Sky subscription to receive digital radio but it is a cheap way of getting brand new equipment. Subscriptions start at £12.50 per month for a minimum of one year, and this generally qualifies for a large discount on the standard installation fee, and at the end of that year you get to keep the equipment. If you don't want to renew your subscription you can then either listen to free-to-air (FTA) stations or get a free-to-view (FTV) card to listen to radio stations and watch the free digital TV channels.

What you'll get for your basic subscription is a Sky digibox which is normally made by Panasonic, Grundig, Pace or Amstrad and you will also get a Minidish. Then all you have to do is to connect the audio output of the receiver to an input on your amplifier or whatever system you have.

Sky now offer a non-subscription installation-only package which costs £120. The only thing that you have to do to get this is to connect your Sky digibox to the phone line so that, when instructed, the Sky digibox phones an 0800 number (usually in the early hours of the morning, and it won't interrupt a call of the line is busy) and then at the end of the 12 months contract you get to keep the satellite system. So, in effect you're getting all the free-to-air (FTA) channels for £120, which includes about the same amount of choice of TV channels as you get on Freeview, but you get far more radio stations on FTA DSat and the bit rates, and hence audio quality, are far superior to DAB.

To contact Sky, their sales phone number is 08705 800 874 or go to Sky's customer service website.

Sky also require that your TV is within 30 feet of a suitable place to put the dish and they do not install to flats. 

 

Installation costs are usually very low if you subscribe to Sky. For example, if you subscribe to one of the premium packages you frequently get installation for £1, then you can downgrade your subscription after you have Sky to one of the cheaper packages, thus taking advantage of the £1 installation charge, but not paying as much for a yearly subscription. For example, if you get a premium package, get the £1 installation offer, then downgrade to the £12.50 per month package after 1 month you save the difference between the standard installation charge and the cost of the premium package.

 

Buying Receiver & Dish

This option lets you buy 2nd hand from places such as Satcure's 2nd hand adverts page, ebay.co.uk or other on-line auction pages or Loot. This also allows you to save on installation costs if you do it yourself (I will post some basic instructions on how to install a satellite system soon).

 

Free to Air (FTA)

Almost all of the radio stations carried on the Sky satellite are FTA. This means that you don't need a card to receive them at all and can receive them on any suitable digital satellite receiver with a dish pointing at the Astra 2A satellite which carries the Sky signals. This gives you the most options because there is no need to have a Sky digibox because the signals are not encrypted using Sky's Videoguard encryption. Unfortunately the digital TV channels cannot be received FTA because they are encrypted by Sky.

 

Free to View (FTV)

If you want to watch ITV1, Channel 4 and five then you will need to get a Solus card from Sky or the BBC. The cards are available for a small one-off payment  For a list of the stations and TV channels available FTA or FTV see here.  

 

PC Card Receiver & Dish

At present there are quite a few PC card satellite receivers such as:

  • Hauppauge WinTV Nexus-s (£169)
  • Hauppauge WinTV Nova (£63)
  • TechniSat SkyStar 1
  • TechniSat SkyStar 2

The most highly recommended DVB-S card is the Hauppauge WinTV DVB-S card. This is suitable for listening to all FTA stations and channels but cannot decode the FTV channels. It is advisable to make sure you have a good sound card as otherwise you will limit the audio quality of the signal. The main advantage of this card is that you can record directly to your hard drive which makes burning CD-Rs very easy. I have a Psion Wavefinder DAB radio for my PC and I would definitely recommend this function. This DVB-S card does not have any of the instability problems that has plagued the Wavefinder.

     

Multiple Receivers

A problem with getting a satellite receiver is that if you use it both for watching digital TV and listening to radio stations then there could be arguments about who uses the receiver. Fortunately you can connect more than one receiver to the dish. What is required here is a universal LNB (low noise block) with a twin output where each output goes to a different receiver. LNBs with more outputs are also available. The LNB is the thing that collects all the signals after they are reflected onto it from the dish surface. The LNB reduces the frequency of the received signal from the 11-12 GHz to a far lower frequency so that they can then travel down the cable to the receiver.

     

Multiple Satellites

To receive signals from more than one satellite you can buy dual or quad LNBs which are still available with twin outputs etc. The different LNBs are held in a special bracket and they are inclined at different angles in relation to the dish so that signals from the different satellites are reflected onto them. This means that there is no need to actually move the dish to look at a different satellite. This is a relatively cheap way of hugely expanding the number of digital radio stations that can be received although the additional stations are from other countries. Classical music fans are well-served in Europe with some stations using high bit rates such as 256 kbps. Two stations that have been recommended are Bayern 4 Klassik and HR Klassik, both of which have reportedly exceptional audio quality.

To receive from different satellites a receiver that has what is called DiSEqC (Digital Satellite Equipment Control) must be purchased but the vast majority of receivers have this function although the Sky digiboxes don't. PC cards will probably all have DiSEqC. To change from one satellite to another all that is required is to control an on-screen menu.

     

Dishes

One thing to bear in mind is that you must get the correct combination of dish and LNB or LNBs. For example, the Minidish that you would get with Sky is oval shaped and has a specially designed LNB that is shaped for oval dishes.

In general the larger the size of the dish the better the signal will be and a large dish should provide some protection against bit errors especially when it is raining. A 80 or 90cm diameter dish should be easily enough and 60cm should be okay. Unless you find there is problems or you want the best possible signal to minimize the likelihood of bit errors then if you have a Sky Minidish then there is probably no point in changing it.

For round dishes a universal LNB is the best one to get and these are very common and quite cheap.